Logo

Why the cheapest quote rarely tells the whole story

Price comparison sites are excellent at ranking quotes by monthly cost, and much less good at telling you whether a policy will actually pay out when you need it. Two home contents policies with an almost identical premium can behave very differently at the point of claim. The gap between a £9 and a £12 monthly premium is £36 a year; the gap between a settled claim and a rejected one can run into thousands. Comparing properly means checking the same details on every quote: sum insured, single-item limits, excesses and exclusions.

Start with your sum insured and single-item limits

Your contents sum insured should reflect what it would cost to replace everything you own at today's prices, not what you paid for it years ago. Underinsuring is the most common and most costly mistake in contents cover, because most policies include an average clause. If you insure £30,000 of contents that would actually cost £60,000 to replace, a £2,000 claim can be reduced to £1,000.

• Walk through your home room by room and estimate replacement costs for furniture, clothing, electronics, tools and sports gear.
• Add the total, then add 10–15% for everything you have forgotten.
• Review it every year, and after any large purchase.

Single-item limits matter just as much. A standard policy might cap cover at £1,500 for any one item, with valuables such as jewellery, watches and art limited to perhaps 15% of the total sum insured. A watch, ring, camera or road bike worth more than the single-item limit needs to be listed separately as a specified item, which usually raises the premium.

Excesses: check both numbers and the ones in the small print

Every policy has a compulsory excess set by the insurer, and most let you add a voluntary excess on top in return for a lower premium. Choose a total excess you could genuinely pay tomorrow, not the largest number that shaves a few pounds off the monthly cost.

Excesses are rarely uniform, so read on, because insurers often apply a higher one to particular claim types:

• Accidental damage: commonly £150–£250.
• Escape of water: often £250–£500.
• Subsidence, heave or landslip: frequently £1,000 or more.

Some policies apply the excess per item, per claim or per event, which matters if several things are stolen at once. And claiming for a £180 item when your excess is £250 simply does not work. Treat the excess as the level below which you self-insure.

Bicycles, laptops and valuables away from home

This is where policies diverge most, and where the cheapest quote usually shows its weakness. Standard cover protects possessions inside the home. Anything that leaves the house — a bike, laptop, phone or camera — may be excluded, capped at a low limit, or covered only if you have paid for personal possessions cover.

For bicycles, check three things: is theft away from home covered at all; what is the per-bike limit, often £500 or £1,000 unless the bike is specified; and what security is required. Many insurers insist on a Sold Secure Gold-rated lock, and some require the bike to be locked to an immovable object even inside a shed or garage. Overnight theft from a public place is frequently excluded.

For laptops and phones, check whether accidental damage is included or sold as an add-on, as mobile phones are sometimes excluded from it altogether. If you work from home, look at the business equipment exclusion too, since many policies cover domestic use only.

Exclusions and conditions that catch people out

• Security conditions: specified door and window locks, the alarm set whenever you go out, and no cover if a key is left in a hiding place.
• Gradual damage: wear and tear, damp, mould, vermin, moths and frost.
• Damage caused by pets, or during DIY and decorating.
• Matching sets: replacing one worktop, tile or length of carpet may cover only the damaged item, not the whole set.
• Money, cards, freezer contents and garden plants, usually with modest fixed limits.
• Leaving the home empty for more than 30 or 60 consecutive days.

You also have a duty to tell your insurer about changes that affect the risk, such as a new high-value item, a lodger or a change of address. An innocent omission can still affect a claim.

How to compare policies like for like

Get at least three quotes using the same sum insured and the same excess, then compare the cover rather than the price alone. The Insurance Product Information Document gives a quick summary, but the full policy wording is where the detail lives. A few practical habits:

• Price up add-ons such as accidental damage and personal possessions cover, and compare the total.
• Check whether paying monthly adds interest, as it often costs 10–30% more than paying annually.
• Look at the claims process and helpline, because that is what you will use when something goes wrong.
• Keep receipts, photographs and serial numbers for higher-value items, stored somewhere other than the house.
• Remember the 14-day cooling-off period if you change your mind.

Finally, think about what you would realistically claim for. Many households now choose a higher excess and claim less often, treating insurance as protection against disasters rather than every cracked screen. That is sensible, provided you know where your cover stops and your savings begin.